“I have come/not to beg nor barter but to enter.”

Gregory Luce | Scene4 Magazine

Gregory Luce

inView

October 2026

gl1026-1

In August 2021, I had the pleasure of reviewing Shara McCallum’s previous collection, No Ruined Stone, a masterful reimagining of the career of Scottish poet Robert Burns had he not found success as a poet. Speculating on Burns’ possible life as a plantation overseer in Jamaica, McCallum explored themes of racism, enslavement, colonialism, and sexual exploitation within the unequal power relationship between master and enslaved.

In her magnificent new collection, Behold, the arrival of which is cause for great joy, McCallum again treats some of these themes refracted through different lenses. It is a much more personal book than No Ruined Stone or that volume’s predecessor Madwoman. The poet here combines personal experience with ekphrasis to create another remarkable collection.

The book’s epigraph from the Book of Hebrews provides both the book’s title and an indication of its themes:

“Behold, I have come—in the volume of the book/it is written of me—To do your will.”
It would seem that that the task at hand is, among other things, to witness and to give a personal accounting.

The opening poem, “Passage,” draws inspiration from composer Marta Gentilucci’s work of the same name, and sets out the poet’s quest:

      I have come
      not to beg nor barter but to enter.
      Who are you seeking?
      The past
      opens and opens, fleshing me
      with loss.
      I descend
      to find my way,
      I who am
      haunted and a haunting….
      How will you return to the living?
      Called back by the susurrating wind and sea.
      Called back by the roots of my hair, dirt
      beneath my nails, the body’s sweat and stink.
      Called back by their voices, yours
      still clenched in my fist. Called back
      to all that is matter, bone, and skin,
      what fragment of you survives in me
      as I open my mouth to speak?”

One path on the poet’s self-discovery journey is through art. A prose poem entitled “Snow” relates her first encounter with original visual art, mingling it with her first time seeing snow:

“The first museum I ever visited was the Metropolitan Museum of Art. I was twenty years old, and it was also my first trip to New York City and first time seeing snow. Growing up mainly in my grandparent’s home after migrating to Miami, I’d been exposed to visual art through my grandmother’s loves…. But, no wonder, when I went to the Met, I made a beeline for the Impressionists. I remember standing in front of a Renoir and realising the obvious: how different the textures and colours of the image were in person. I remember I kept running back and forth between the painting and the oversized windows that looked out onto Central Park to watch the snow that had begun falling.”

McCallum’s engagement with art is made manifest in many ekphrastic poems that consider the work of artists who may be otherwise overlooked. “Crop Time,” a painting by Jamaican artist Albert Huie, evokes a not-so-distant past in the land in which the poet was born.

gl1026-2

      Pastoral
      This is the Jamaica you were not born
      into. In this field the artist has layered
      bodies of labourers, hefting wrapped
      bundles of sugar cane, lifting these
      onto bull-drawn carts….
      a grey cluster
      of buildings, smokestacks, smoke
      wreathing up to the sky. The smell,
      that burning is in you still.

In “Self-Portrait,” the poet turns an artist’s eye to herself, attempting to come to terms with her mixed racial and cultural heritage. I quote in full:

      At this point, I don’t know what in me is Jamaican
      versus American. Or, reaching further back,
      Trinidadian, Venezuelan, African, Scottish, English...
      you get the drift. I thought every mickle mek a muckle
      was from Kingston soil sprung, until in Edinburgh
      I heard it in the mouth of a Scotsman. For years, I filed
      my grandmother’s doudou as Patwa, failing to detect
      Trini-French patois in her mongrel dialect.
      How do you say aluminum or Armageddon? Ah, for me,
      there interposes an extra syllable, an invisible I.
      And why should any one I matter?
      is a fair question.
      Only because the alternative is worse. And since
      we’re on the topic of the singular, about this subject:
      she’s awfully tired of being parsed to see if she’s a
      fraud.

And this passage from another prose poem, “How to See”:

“When I decided to become a poet, it was after letting go the paths—medicine or, if that failed, law—I was expected to be on by attending university. Only then, when I saw I was actually going to throw my life away, did I take two art classes.

In the first, introduction to drawing, I worked with pen, pencil, and charcoal on paper….
The second was an advanced art history class I chose because the time period it covered included a few of the European painters (Impressionists) whose works I loved and, as an English major, I thought I’d find interpretation of text to be in my wheelhouse…. My professor, not so inclined as my drawing instructor had been to gentle critique, plainly and continually reminded me of my lack. Every essay was returned with a variation on this theme: Shara, you need to learn how to see what the artist is asking and stop imposing your own desires unto the art.”

gl1026-3

A painting by another Jamaican artist, John Dunkley, leads the speaker into a meditation on the mythic connection between the people of the island and its natural setting. Again quoted in full:

      Parable
      There is a story told of a woman
      who would leave her home, her children
      in their beds, to walk to the cliff ledge
      jutting over the ravine. Night’s face
      shone on her sometimes, dredging her
      in silver light, at other turns netting her
      in its lack. Long dead, a tree stump
      on the bank below sprouted a leaf,
      each of its veins glowing. For a time,
      she became this nightly walking
      to the river to lean into the dark, feeding
      the fishes she could not see clustering
      on the surface. Her feet practicing
      this path though there was no path.

This collection is so rich and varied that as always I wish I could share many more passages.

The poet’s journey remains unfinished but in the final poem it takes her “On the Road to Zion,” another ekphrastic poem devoted to an unknown Jamaican artist.

      To reach you must walk backwards,
      past cane fields ravelling smoke.
      Pay no mind to the girl-child, roadside
      in her dutty dress, transfixed by the goat
      struggling against its rope. She misplaced
      her soul long ago in its bleating.
      To avoid such a fate, you cannot dillydally,
      but must keep moving till you cross over
      duppy road and come to the house
      of the blind woman, at the junction
      of riverbed and mountain. Then
      may you lift up your eyes and behold
      the one who has been waiting
      all this time for you to arrive.

Behold is a book to acquire and savor in full.
Order it from Alice James Books.

gl1026-4
Shara McCallum is the author of seven books published in the US & UK, including Behold, No Ruined Stone, and Madwoman. Recognition for her work includes a Guggenheim Fellowship, NEA Poetry Fellowship, Musgrave Medal, OCM Bocas Poetry Prize, Hurston/Wright Legacy Award, and others. From Jamaica, of Jamaican and Venezuelan parentage, McCallum directs the Creative Writing Program and teaches at Penn State, where she is a Sparks Professor of English.

As previously, Shara was gracious enough to take the time to answer a few questions about Behold.

This book seems more autobiographical than your previous two. What led you to this more personal theme? How does if fit with your other work?

You are the second person to ask me about autobiography in conjunction with Behold. It makes sense since I’ve included prose meditations that are clearly autobiographical and also have a series of poems in the collection titled ‘Self-Portrait.’ Obviously, I’m inviting the reader to see the “I” as “Shara,” at least in those pieces, if not also others by extrapolation. I can’t really say what made me write with more self-disclosure this go round, but I suspect aging has something to do with the matter. As we get older, perhaps the masks we’ve worn earlier in our lives don’t suit us as much or we get tired of keeping them in place. In terms of your second question here, I’ve long been interested in the self as a construct. Behold comes out of and I hope extends that thread of enquiry from previous books.

In “How to See” you write:

“When I decided to become a poet, it was after letting go the paths—medicine or, if that failed, law—I was expected to be on by attending university. Only then, when I saw I was actually going to throw my life away, did I take two art classes.”

So your interest in art began at the same time as you decided to become a poet. How did you decide on poetry?

Actually, my interest in art (music, dance, painting, poetry, and more) has been a constant my whole life. The piece you’re quoting from is reflecting on a particular moment, when I was at university, and saw very clearly that I was going to devote myself to trying to make art. I saw that I would approach poetry not as a passing fancy but as my avocation. I think like many people who write poems, poetry partly decided on me. I also write essays but not nearly with the same regularity nor near-compulsion I feel where poems are concerned. What I love about poetry is its ability to create a musical, metaphoric, mythic, memory-laden world, story, and speaking
voice. I also really revel in repetition. I’m the kind of person who obsessively listens to one song or watches a show over and over again. All art invites and rewards repeated engagement. Poetry has repetition as a premium, as poems remake meaning with recursive reading/listening.

The collection contains many ekphrastic poems along with reminiscences about creating art yourself, visiting museums, etc. As a follow up to the previous question, why have you now decided to make art and your experiences with it central to your poetry?

Again, this is a great question to which I’m not sure I have a precise answer. I didn’t start the book with an idea of what it would be about. I was lucky to have a fellowship that gave me a year away from teaching, and I decided I would use that time to visit as many museums as I could and seek out works by other Black, Caribbean, Latin American, women artists and see what came of that. I really love visiting museums, especially going by myself and wandering around and looking at the art. I read the Romantic poets as a young person and was deeply influenced by many of their thoughts on poetry and life. The impressions they gave of the value of trying to reach the Sublime resonated with me. I still very much want the dailiness of my life to be punctured by something awe-inspiring. Looking at art is one of the ways I experience the disruption of the ordinary and of routines. Art makes me pay attention.

Madwomanand No Ruined Stone both draw on your racial and ethnic heritage, particularly the Jamaican and Scottish elements. How does Behold follow from those books?

Those elements of my identity and my negotiations of history are also throughout Behold. As Marley said and I love to quote: “you can’t run away from yourself.” Nor am I trying to do so in Behold. Often the opposite: I’m examining how I see myself and am seen, now and in this political moment. I hope this book adds to the question of inheritance I asked in my previous two, which you mention. Many of the poems in Behold speak to my Jamaican &/vs. American selves, to my ancestors, to migrations, colonisation, and slavery, to violence and survival.

And finally, the word “behold” has clear biblical connotations and you have an epigraph from The Book of Hebrews at the beginning of the book. Could one say that Behold is in part a book of witnessing?

Thank you for this, Greg. Yes, I not only hope one could but that one would say exactly what you are suggesting: Behold is about witnessing. It’s ironic how much of my life I’ve spent trying to look clearly and honestly—at the past, at others, at myself, at art now…—and still feeling inadequate to the task.

 

Share This Page

View readers’ comments in Letters to the Editor


Gregory Luce is a Senior Writer and columnist for Scene4.
He is the author of five books of poetry, has published widely in print and online and is the 2014 Larry Neal Award winner for adult poetry, given by the DC Commission on the Arts and Humanities. Retired from National Geographic, he is a volunteer writing tutor/mentor for 826DC, and lives in Arlington, VA.
More at: https://dctexpoet.wordpress.com/
For his other columns and articles in Scene4 check the Archives.

©2026 Gregory Luce
©2026 Publication Scene4 Magazine

 

YOUR SUPPORT

If you are enjoying what you’re reading please consider adding your support.
Scene4 is a global magazine featuring reviews, commentary, essays, fiction, photography, paintings, graphics and poetry. Founded as a monthly in 2000, with over 300 issues during the past 26 years of publication and an accessible, comprehensive archive now with over 18,000 pages (a unique array of articles most as contemporary as when they were first published). In these disruptive times, we need your help and support to weather the storm. Please make a contribution of any amount by going to our support page here and collect in return the sincere appreciation of our authors,
artists and editors and the continuation of Scene4.

October 2026

About

Cover   This Issue   inFocus   inView   inSight   Perspectives   Special Issues

  Masthead   Your Support   Submissions   Archives   What’s New   Books

 

  Comments   Letters   Subscribe   Contact Us

Search Archives | Share This Page

Scene4 is a print magazine on the web and designed to be read on a monitor or tablet. To read it on a phone, click the phone’s landscape button and
view the pages in landscape mode.

Scene4 (ISSN 1932-3603), published monthly by Scene4 Internationl Magazine
of Arts and Culture. Copyright © 2000-2026 Aviar-Dka Ltd – Aviar Media Llc.