It's
one
of
the
indelible
images
of
American
history:
14
year-old
Mary
Ann
Vecchio
crying
out
in
anguished
disbelief
as
she
kneels
over
the
dead
body
of
Jeffrey
Miller,
one
of
four
college
students
gunned
down
by
Ohio
National
Guardsmen
at
Kent
State
University
on
May
4,
1970.
The
picture
earned
the
photojournalism
student
who
took
it,
John
Filo,
the
Pulitzer
Prize
in
1971.
When
Neil
Young
saw
that
shocking
photo,
he
immediately
wrote
a
song
and
within
weeks
he
and
bandmates
David
Crosby,
Steven
Stills,
and
Graham
Nash
recorded
"Ohio."
Atlantic
Records
expedited
production
to
have
it
on
the
radio
by
June.
Last
June,
Billy
Squier
experienced
what
he
described
as
"a
Neil
Young
moment,"
his
call
to
musical
arms
prompted
by
the
Supreme
Court's
egregious
decision
in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization to overturn Roe v. Wade and Planned Parenthood v. Casey,
stripping
what
will
mainly
be
underprivileged
American
women
of
their
reproductive
rights
in
one
giant
retrograde
leap.
You
better
believe
Squier
feels
strongly
about
the
issue;
while
he
has
performed
at
select
gigs
and
made
guest
appearances
over
the
years,
he
walked
away
from
the
ever-increasingly
corporate
music
industry
in
the
1990s
and
hasn't
recorded
any
new
material
since
2008—something
you'd
never
know
listening
to
"Harder on a Woman,"
the
song
he
wrote
last
year
in
response
and
released
just
last
month.
It's unmistakably Billy Squier. For starters, his voice sounds amazing. The
fact that for years now Squier prefers to spend his time gardening or
maintaining the green spaces of Manhattan's Central Park speaks to his
healthy priorities. You can hear the payoff: he still owns his timbre, still
commands the high notes, still delivers those lilting intonations which
make his vocals instantly recognizable ever since the big hits of Don't Say
No in 1981. In "Harder on A Woman" he often has nowhere to hide with
much of his singing a cappella or close to it. That's unmistakably Billy
Squier swagger.
Don't know if it's homage or a coincidence, but the opening guitar lick,
played twice, sounds a lot like those now iconic closing notes of Neil
Young's "Cinnamon Girl" but with a swampy Blues texture. On the chorus,
the melody gives more than a nod to the power riff of "Everybody Wants
You," another monster hit for Squier on his 1982 Emotions in Motion LP.
Either way, Billy's electric guitar hums with its signature metallic menace.
Nothing's changed: he knows how to craft a tune with hooks, chops, and
punch.
What's different about "Harder On a Woman" is the message, a punch with
a different fist. On Billy's perfect album, Don't Say No, all the songs hang
together around a kind of young man's introspection: "In the Dark,"
"Lonely Is the Night," "Too Daze Gone," "I Need You," "Nobody Knows,"
and the majestic title track. This cut looks outward; like Neil Young's
"Ohio," "Harder On a Woman" is a protest song. It's not in the style of a
Bob Dylan full-on finger pointer like "The Lonesome Death of Hattie
Carroll," "Who Killed Davey Moore?," or "Hurricane." Squier calls out our
country's ugliness and ills in more generic terms, making veiled reference
to the issue, as well as the names. But it seems pretty clear to me he alludes
to Justice Clarence Thomas at the end of the first salvo of lyrics:
Molly's got a problem —
What's she gonna do?
They took away her freedoms,
Can't believe it's true.
Black man at the courthouse says "we're comin' after you" —
He forgets what it's like.
Ouch. Thomas, the court's lone Black Justice, was one of the six Supremes
who saw fit to uphold Mississippi's barbaric 2018 law (Chief Justice John
Roberts joined that majority but didn't go along with overturning Roe v.
Wade or Planned Parenthood v. Casey.) Squier justly chastises Clarence
Thomas with the line "he forgets what it's like"—abortion is a civil rights
issue, a cause for which far better Black men and women than him fought
and died.
Squier's open-ended critique continues in a later stanza:
But in the chorus, which contains the song's title refrain, Billy Squier shifts
from righteous indignation to something you won't find much of in our
toxic culture of feigned outrage and all-too-real anger: empathy. It's
certainly a sensibility sorely lacking in the antediluvian minds who
comprise a majority of the bench of America's highest court:
It's harder on a woman than it is on a man,
Try to love you, baby, best as I can.
She don't want to fight, she don't want to scream,
She just wanna dance, she just wanna sing.
It's harder on a woman than it is on a man,
Try to hold you, darling, long as I can.
She don't want to shout, she don't want to cry
She don't want to listen to the lie, lie, lies.
You can listen to "Harder on a Woman" on Spotify and YouTube. Send the
link to your Senator while you're at it. It's good to hear a vibrant Billy
Squier making new music—alas, for the wrong reason. Billy would rather
be in his garden or tending to the trees of Central Park. If he picks up his
Gibson Les Paul, he'd prefer to play and sing for the sheer joy of it and the
pleasure of his audience. But like the best of them, he couldn't see injustice
and hold his tongue. Someone needed to remind America "it's harder on a
woman than it is on a man."
|