Different
as they were,
all had been
stamped with
the imprint of
history before
they were
thirty.
They belonged
to a century
of shifting
values where
the Jekylls of
one decade
were the Hydes
of the
next. (Louise
Tanner)
Occasionally
when I pass my
much too full
bookshelf, a
book calls out
to me.
It beckons to
me…come
hither and
read. The last
book to do
that is titled Here Today… by
Louise Tanner
published in
1959. A
book no doubt,
I bought at
some yard
sale, thrift
store or
library sale
as I'm oft to
do. In
it, she
chronicles the
meteoric rise
and
precipitous
fall of some
of the early
to mid-20th century American celebrated figures. Well, they were celebrated until they weren't. And that's the point of the book.
By seeing into
the inner
character and
discerning an
underlying
truth, Tanner
cuts through
the legend
like a skilled
surgeon and
reveals the
flawed human
beings that
they always
were.
Tanner
explores the
lives of F.
Scott
Fitzgerald,
Charles
Lindbergh,
Harold
Russell,
Shirley
Temple, and
James Dean to
name a
few.
These figures
according to
Tanner
represented a
"state of mind
which was
briefly either
popular or
notorious".
For
Fitzgerald:
It was the
disillusionment
of the Jazz
Age with its
underlay of
"hick-town
hope".
For
Lindbergh:
It was faith
in the
promises of
science and
the
isolationism
that became
obsolete in
the world he
helped shrink.
For Harold
Russell:
It was a
father's
promise on
Armistice Day
that there
would never be
another war.
For Shirley
Temple:
It was a
director's
promise that
babyhood could
be prolonged
indefinitely.
For James
Dean: It
was the
angst-ridden
rebel carrying
his protests
to a logical
conclusion in
a thrill
packed moment
behind a
splintering
windshield.
Eventually,
all these
highly
esteemed
personalities
ran afoul of
public taste,
public
sentiment, or
savaged their
own careers by
their
behavior.
Fitzgerald
toward the end
of his career
tried to
succeed in the
movie business
– the
last refuge of
scoundrels.
He would fall
prey to his
alcoholism and
his crazed
wife
Zelda.
Lindbergh
would briefly
flee to Europe
after the
kidnapping and
death of his
son. He
would come
back to
America with a
sympathy
bordering on
out and out
advocacy for
the burgeoning
Nazi
regime.
As Tanner put
it, "he came
home to face
the long
ordeal of
deification".
Shirley Temple
of course,
grew up and
was no longer
Shirley
Temple.
The call went
out for the
next
Shirley.
It's been
going out for
almost 100
years.
Many are
called, but
few are
chosen.
And those who
are, can
recount the
tragedies of
child
stardom.
James Dean
lived fast,
died young,
and left
behind a not
so beautiful
corpse.
His rival,
Marlon Brando,
became
corpulent and
irrelevant in
his old
age.
Harold Russell
was not
singled out
for his inner
flaws, but the
outer flaw of
losing his
hands during a
military
training
exercise.
He had the
fortuitous
experience of
appearing in a
supporting
role in the
film The
Best Years Of
Our
Lives. He
would win an
Academy award
for the role
of a Navy
sailor who
lost both
hands during
the war.
However,
Russell's film
career was
brief.
Director
William Wyler
convinced him
that he should
go to college
because there
wasn't much
call for a guy
with no hands
in the motion
picture
industry.
Here Today… is genius because it not only relays a cautionary tale about the perils of fame of a long-ago generation, but her "shifting archetypes" are relevant to today's generation: the lecherous movie mogul, the disgraced president, the mentally ill pop star, the viral sensations that flamed out, the self-destructive actor as well as all those who have succumbed to cancel culture and #themetoomovement.
Unfortunately,
Tanner
inadvertently
created the
archetype of
the "forgotten
writer".
And that's a
shame, because
sometimes an
old dusty book
reveals
insight and
wisdom that
stands the
test of time.
|