I am sometimes a bit late to come to things, and certainly Lizzo is one of them.
But her profile in the November issue of Vanity Fair and the pearl-clutching kerfuffle over her playing of James Madison's crystal flute at the Library of Congress (more on that in a moment) made me spend a nice Saturday morning watching Lizzo videos and tracking down the batshit ramblings of people like Ben Shapiro.
I
like
her
videos
and
I
liked
her
profile.
She's
entertaining,
raunchy,
loving,
high
spirited,
confident
and
fun.
The
flute
thing?
Back
in
September,
Carla
Hayden,
director
of
the
Library
of
Congress
(who
also
happens
to
be
the
first
woman
and
first
Black
person
to
be
director
of
the
LoC),
reached
out
to
Lizzo,
who
is
a
trained
flautist,
to
play
a
crystal
flute
belonging
to
James
Madison,
the
fourth
American
president
who
was
a
slaveowner
(who
never
freed
his
slaves,
even
at
his
death),
architect
of
the
three-fifths-of-a-person
calculus
for
slaves
in
the
Constitution
and
head
of
the
effort
to
deport
all
freed
Blacks
to
Liberia.
She
played
it
at
the
LoC
and
then
later
at
her
Washington,
D.C.,
concert
(videos
of
both
are
easily
found
online).
And,
to
make
it
even
more
special,
this
Black
woman
of
pop
culture
fame
was
the
first
person
to
ever
play
the
flute,
given
as
a
gift
to
Madison
by
Claude
Laurent,
a
French
crystal
flute
maker
(I
guess
that
was
a
thing
then),
to
celebrate
his
second
term.
And
Western
civilization
collapsed,
at
least
on
the
right
side
of
the
political
seesaw,
because
Lizzo,
in
playing
the
flute
at
her
concert,
twerked
when
she
did.
(Though,
if
you
watch
Lizzo's
entertaining
TED
Talk
on
the
origins
of
twerking
–
dubbed
in
one
link
as
a
TED
Twerk
–
what
she
did
in
D.C.
when
she
played
the
flute
was,
at
best,
a
twerkette,
a
slight
butt
shake
to
make
a
funny
point.)
Forbes did a nice job of compiling some of the strenuous right-wing upchucks, to wit:
For
some
reason,
the
simple
act
of
twerking
is
a
move
guaranteed
to
boil
the
blood
of
right-wing
culture
warriors;
it's
their
kryptonite,
a
dance
move
which
practically
requires
a
trigger
warning
in
advance,
lest
they
burst
a
blood
vessel
in
blinding
rage.
Jenna
Ellis,
a
former
campaign
lawyer
for
Donald
Trump,
said
Lizzo's
performance
was
a
"desecration,
purposefully,
of
America's
history."
Matt
Walsh,
a
right-wing
influencer,
described
Lizzo's
performance
as
"a
form
of
racial
retribution,
according
to
the
woke
Left."
Strategist
Greg
Price
tweeted:
"The
Library
of
Congress
really
took
out
a
200-year-old
flute
that
belonged
to
James
Madison
just
so
Lizzo
could
twerk
with
it.
They
degrade
our
history
and
then
call
you
racist
if
you
actually
value
it."
James
Bradley,
who
is
currently
running
for
US
Senate
in
California,
compared
Lizzo's
performance
to
somebody
taking
"a
dump
on
the
American
flag."
Of
course,
Ben
Shapiro
also
chimed
in,
framing
Lizzo's
actions
as
deliberately
provocative,
essentially
blaming
her
for
the
reactionary
backlash.
"If
all
we
had
seen
was
the
clip
of
Lizzo
playing
the
flute
in
the
halls
of
the
Library
of
Congress
while
wearing
a
semi-modest
outfit,
everyone
would
have
shrugged.
But
that's
not
the
clip
everyone
championed
as
groundbreaking:
it
was
the
clip
where
she
bragged
about
twerking."
Shapiro,
on
one
of
his
podcasts,
talks
about
how
the
actions
of
this
"significantly
overweight
African
American
woman"
vulgarized
(that
was
his
word)
American
history
and
degraded
both
the
culture
and
the
gentility
(yes,
that
was
his
word)
of
America's
founders.
And cue the long sigh, the rueful shaking of the head.
Would
that
we
lived
in
a
country
that
could
see
that
what
the
LoC
and
Lizzo
did,
without
a
great
deal
of
fanfare
or
hype,
was
the
closest
thing
this
country
can
have
at
this
moment
to
an
act
of
grace,
a
salvific
act
that
was,
at
the
same
time,
historic,
fun,
shattering
and
healing:
a
woman
James
Madison
would
have
enslaved
playing
a
flute
owned
by
the
American
people
offered
to
her
by
another
woman
Madison
would
have
enslaved
in
a
building
owned
by
the
American
people
in
a
moment
of
common
enjoyment
infused
with
a
feeling
of
satisfaction
at
the
progress
made
by
the
American
experiment
to
create
a
multidimensional
democracy.
Like Lizzo said, history can be freaking cool.
|