The following piece
was written nine years
ago, but it remains
just as relevant
today. The
recent incursion of
Hamas terrorists who
flooded into Israel
causing death and
destruction only
amplifies what I have
previously stated
about Israel and its
place in the
world. The piece
ostensibly dealt with
prominent figures in
the music industry who
scorned the Jewish
state (that hasn't
changed) but also
linked the past with
the present –
the endless war that
the Israelis must
fight for their right
to exist.
It's extremely
difficult for
entertainers to stay
out of politics.
Even when one does
their damnest to stay
out of a political
fight one can be seen
as for one side or the
other just by their
inaction. Take
for example the age
old Middle East
conflict between
Israel and the
Palestinians.
According to an August
28th article in Rolling Stone magazine,
summer 2014 was
supposed to be the
biggest and baddest
concert season in
Israeli history.
May and June brought
concerts by megastars
Justin Timberlake and
the Rolling Stones
seemingly without any
controversy. But
in July, everything
blew
up…literally. The
Hamas controlled Gaza
Strip erupted in
violence and longtime
Palestinian advocate
and former Pink Floyd
band member Roger
Waters began to exert
undue influence over
his fellow
artists. He
persuaded many artists
including Neil Young
to cancel Israeli
concert
dates. Many
cited "security
concerns" as their
stated reason for
abandoning Israeli
fans.
Really??? When
has there not been
some sort of security
concern in Israel and
the Middle East in
general? Despite
the constant turmoil
between Israel and its
Arab neighbors, it
remains a bastion of
safety and security in
the region. It
has enhanced its
security with the Iron
Dome Interception Unit
(IDIS) which so far
has intercepted every
rocket fired from the
Gaza Strip. With
all due respect and
condolences to family
members who have lost
brave journalists and
humanitarians due to
beheadings, Israel is
one place in the
Middle East where you
don't have to worry
about finding Neil
Young on a stick.
Other performers such
as Nick Carter of The
Backstreet Boys
dismiss their
reluctance to perform
by stating, "We're
entertainers –
it's not our job to
take sides". But
going back to my
original
point…they're
clearly in the
Palestinian camp.
Why do celebrity remarks and actions matter at all when it comes to
Israel? It's
due to the nature of
celebrity
itself.
Celebrities are often
taken more seriously
than well reasoned and
thoughtful experts
when it comes to the
subject of the
Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. Perception
is reality…
unfortunately. But
being pro-Israeli
doesn't mean one is
anti-Palestinian.
The vast population in
the Gaza Strip lives
in deplorable
conditions. But
where does the fault
lie? When the
Israelis departed
Gaza, they left behind
highly technical
agricultural and
industrial
installations.
What they got in
return was a shower of
rockets. The
Palestinian people
have been ill served
by the Hamas
leadership. They
may be hailed as
heroes within the
confines of Gaza, but
the hospitals,
mosques, and schools
they build for their
constituency are often
turned into weapons
storage depots. Follow
the money- the funding
coming from the U.N,
the U.S., E.U. and the
Saudi's and see how
much actually trickles
down to needy families
in the West Bank and
Gaza.
One of the key issues
plaguing any peace
agreement between the
two parties hinges on
the Palestinians
demand of the right of
return. This
would mean that
approximately 600,000
refugees of the 1948
War of Independence
and their descendents
(some have put the
number as high as five
million) would be
allowed to flood
Israel and to
overwhelm the Jewish
state thus destroying
it from within.
Israel already
incorporates into its
population a million
Arab citizens as it is
in a land mass that is
just barely larger
than the state of New
Jersey. So you
see that demand is a
non-starter.
Even if the Israelis
wanted to negotiate,
who would they
negotiate with?
It is fairly clear
Hamas will never
recognize Israel as a
state. How can
you sit down with
someone in earnest
peace talks when they
don't recognize your
right to exist?
There are no Anwar
Sadats out there or on
the horizon. One
almost pines for the
good old days of
Yassar Arafat.
For all his faults, at
least he came around
to recognizing Israel
and would sit down at
the negotiating table.
Has Israel overreached
at times in its
struggle to maintain
peace and
security? You
bet it has, as any
nation might that was
created out of the
ashes of the Nazi
Holocaust and on the
very day of that
creation was invaded
by five neighboring
Arab states. Mr.
Waters has compared
Israel with the Nazis
and has even flown pig
balloons at concerts
with a Star of David
prominently displayed
on it. It's also
no surprise that
Waters is part of the
pro-Palestinian group
BDS (Boycott,
Divestment, and
Sanctions)
The group contains
academics, writers as
well as entertainers
in its ranks who seek
to deprive Israel
economically and
culturally until they
heed to Palestinian
demands. Other
prominent members
include Alice Walker,
Danny Glover, David
Byrne, and Jane
Fonda. And while
they seek to thwart
musical festivals,
plays, and films
withinIsrael pray tell
me where their films,
plays, and music will
ever be listened to
and heard in the Arab
world? Will ISIS
or the Saudis ever
allow Danny Glover's Lethal Weapon 56
(or whatever he's up
to now) be shown in
territory they
control? No way
in hell. Such
"decadent" western
influences will not be
tolerated. And
what about the
treatment of women in
these Arab
lands? Any
comments about that
Ms. Fonda?
Pull back from the
Middle East map and
you will see Israel is
not the neighborhood
bully it is often
portrayed to be.
With the exception of
the Jordanians and the
Egyptians (very shaky
at this point), Israel
is surrounded by Arab
states and entities
who want to see it
utterly
destroyed. Mr.
Waters, a little
balance is in
order. You see
there is no middle
ground. As we
say in Texas the only
things in the middle
of the road are yellow
stripes and dead
armadillos.
|