If I had my way
I would move
To another lifetime.
I’d quit my job,
Ride the train through the misty nighttime.
I’d be ready when my feet touched ground
Wherever I come down
And if the folks will have me
Then they’ll have me:
Any world that I’m welcome to [X3]
Is better
Than the one
I come from.
—Steely Dan, “Any World That I’m Welcome To”
My epigraph comes from a
song that has moved me to
moistened eyes and
head-shaking smiles many a
time; they’re lines
from one of the many
priceless musical gifts
bequeathed us by Donald
Fagen and Walter Becker,
better known as Steely Dan.
Sometimes, when the world
overwhelms me with its
violence and vulgarity,
its obscenity, even its
banality, there are also films to which I return much the same way one needs the refuge of a song or certain friends or one’s family, the haven of a familiar home, or the comfort of a favorite milieu, be it the beach or mountains or just a nearby park.
For me, one of those films is Midnight in Paris,
Woody Allen’s
life-affirming,
soul-restoring masterpiece
of 2011.
If you had told me the
plot before I’d seen
it, I would never have
believed I would enjoy Midnight in Paris, let alone adore it. As with my reading predilections, I crave reality. I believe there should be a 20-year moratorium on all Star Wars films. I can’t tell you how tiresome I find zombies (besides, with smartphones and ear-buds, who needs celluloid zombies—the streets teem with real ones!) Vampires, CGI, the firehose of apocalyptic action that are Marvel movies . . . enough! So the idea that even an incredibly amiable screenwriter and wannabe novelist—main character Gil Pender, played by Owen Wilson—slips through a wrinkle in time each midnight to find himself back in A
Moveable Feast-era Paris would normally nix it for me.
But Woody makes it
impossible to resist,
having mastered his
material, perfected his
angles, his eye and ear
trained, tuned, and both
pitch perfect. He begins
with that glorious series
of shots of contemporary
Paris (more like portraits)—a
heart-swelling
homage—mated to a
ravishing Jazz masterpiece
from 1953, “Si tu
vois ma mére”
(“If you see my
mother”), a song
written and performed by
Sidney Bechet. Originally
from New Orleans, Bechet,
a legendary soprano
saxophonist, clarinetist,
and composer, moved to
Paris in 1951. In the
context of those
portraits, Bechet’s
song sounds as if two
cities fell in love, New
Orleans walking
hand-in-hand with Paris,
wooing her every swinging
step of the way, its echo
effect like NoLa saying
“I love you”
with the City of Lights
replying “I love you
too.”
And then there’s the
film’s delightful
theme song, “Bistro
Fada,” written and
performed by contemporary
French guitarist Stéphane
Wrembel. I point out
“contemporary”
because you might
otherwise think the song
was a classic by Gypsy
Jazz great (and Paris
sensation) Django
Reinhardt. Allen weaves
this Romani-inflected,
full-on jangly Django
tribute throughout the
movie. It often reminds me
of the famed “Third
Man Theme” played by
Austrian zither player
Anton Karas and which
director Carol Reed
deployed to equally
memorable effect.
Midnight in Paris delivers continuous pleasure; I enjoy every scene and anticipate so many with relish. It’s a Woody Allen film, so the laughs abound. The castings delight me every time. I’d never taken Owen Wilson seriously before, but his wholesale absorption of Woody Allen’s persona and delivery, as well as his own contributions to the character of Gil Pender blew me away: bravo! Kathy Bates as Gertrude Stein: brilliant! Tom Hiddleston and Alison Pill’s F. Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald: exactly how I imagine them! And Adrien Brody’s Salvador Dalí and his preoccupation with the rhinoceros—damn, that never fails to make me howl!
I could lavish paragraphs
on scene after scene, but
I’ll choose
one—maybe my
favorite—to show you
why Midnight in Paris is a place I go to feel good. Or better.
I have a concept called
the Mini-Oscar: the
Academy ought to award
diminutive versions of its
gold statues to an actor
or actress for a
particularly memorable scene.
Perhaps the whole role
didn’t merit
“Best
Actor/Actress,” but
the performance in this
one scene deserves
recognition.
With his whiskers and eyes
a-twinkle, Robert Shaw
earned one as Quint in Jaws when he instantly sobered up his two crew members—Roy Scheider and Richard Dreyfuss—with his riveting tale of how he survived the sinking and subsequent shark feeding-frenzy of the USS Indianapolis (Shaw deserved extra credit as he wrote that scene himself.) You won’t find a more eloquent soliloquy in film—the factual details, the surprising bonhomie and conversational warmth, those startlingly poetic observations.
Corey Stoll’s portrayal of the young Moveable Feast-years
Hemingway earns my nod for
a Mini-Oscar.
Gil meets up with Hem a
second time when that
magical car (a 1928
Peugeot Type 184
Landaulet) pulls up at the
stroke of midnight. Gil
gets in the back
(practically a small salon
with window shades) and
Stoll, as the swaggering
young expat, sans greeting
or preface, launches into
this wonderful delivery:
The assignment was to
take the hill. There were
four of us—five if
you counted Vicente but
he had lost his hand when
a grenade went off and
couldn’t fight as
he could when I first met
him. And he was young and
brave and the hill was
soggy from days of rain
and it sloped down toward
a road and there were
many German soldiers on
the road and the idea was
to aim for the first
group and if our aim was
true we could delay them.
The exchange that follows is essential Woody Allen humor, his classic blend of self-effacement, sanity, and humanity. Sideswiped by what must be a passage from a short story or novel in the works, Gil asks Hemingway if he was scared. Knowing the answer, Hem still asks: “of what?”
Gil: “Getting killed.”
To which Hemingway
instantly replies:
“You’ll never
write well if you fear
dying. Do you?”
Gil responds: “Yeah,
I do, it’s probably,
it would probably be my
greatest fear,
actually.”
“Well it’s something all men before you have done, all men will do.”
“I know, I know.”
Then Hemingway takes a
different tack:
“Have you ever made
love to a truly great
woman?”
Gil lights up: “Actually my fiancée is pretty sexy.”
“And when you make
love to her you feel true
and beautiful passion and
you, for at least that
moment, lose your fear of
death.”
“No, that doesn’t happen.”
And then, with no
hesitation, Hemingway
drops this tour de force
declaration of principles
on a wide-eyed Gil:
I believe that love that
is true and real creates
a respite from death. All
cowardice comes from not
loving or not loving
well, which is the same
thing. And when the man
who is brave and true
looks death squarely in
the face like some rhino
hunters I know or
Belmonte, who’s
truly brave, it is
because they love with
sufficient passion to
push death out of their
minds—until it
returns, as it does to
all men, and then you
must make really good love again…. Think about it.
Amen. One of my favorite
scenes in any movie! And
you better believe I can
recite all those lines and
occasionally blindside a
friend or acquaintance
with “the assignment
was to take the
hill….”
There are several other
portals through which
characters slip in the
film, most notably and
poignantly when a
horse-drawn carriage pulls
up to transport Gil and
his 1920s love interest
Adriana back to La Belle
Époque. They visit the
Moulin Rouge where they
have an instructive
conversation with
Toulouse-Lautrec, Gauguin,
and Degas. For Adriana, Paris was Paris in La Belle Époque; the three artists feel that the city peaked during the Renaissance.
Gil has an epiphany and
sees how every generation
looks longingly to an
earlier time, a
“beautiful
era.” Adriana
decides to stay in Belle
Époque Paris. Gil finds
new love in the Paris of
the present day. But it
was Woody Allen and his
glorious opening portraits
of the city one summer
afternoon who told us
right at the start that
Paris is still Paris,
juiced with joie de vivre.
The present age is the
only one in which we get
to live. If I can’t
go back to a better,
vanished time or the Paris
of earlier eras, I can
always return to my
cinematic refuge. And if
the folks will have me,
then they’ll have me.
|