sc4-962-3d1

On the Grounds of Reality

Michael Bettencourt | Scene4 Magazine

Michael Bettencourt

My current creative project, other than spring garden work (oh, what fun that is), is adapting David Greig’s The Book of I, published last year by Europa. Greig is a prolific and celebrated playwright from Scotland, but he had never written a proper book before this. (There is an excellent review of the book by Meghan O’Gieblyn in the March 26 issue of New York Review of Books.)

The Book of I had an unlikely starting point. Greig, a playwright, was invited to write a thriller on Scottish history for a series of novellas aimed at tourists. He found that the not-usual-for-him format was ultimately freeing, allowing him to delve into an actual historical event: the sacking of the monastery on the island of Iona by Vikings in 825 A.D. in search of a reliquary that contained the bones of Saint Columba.

Greig tells his story of destruction, reconstruction and transformation through four characters.

Martin is a young monk who is the only survivor after the Vikings slaughter about a dozen monks, including the abbot, who is literally torn limb from limb by four horses. The only reason he survives is because he hides in the shitpool of the latrine.

Grimur is one of the Vikings who attack the monastery, but he finds himself pleasantly overwhelmed by the sweet mead made by Una, the wife of the blacksmith (whom Grimur has dispatched with an ax). Thus freed, Una seems to greatly enjoy inebriating the man who did the deed (and whom she later accepts into her bed).

Bronagh is a young woman from wealth who travels to the island, once the Vikings have left and Martin, Grimur and Una rebuild it as their home, to become an anchoress, an impulse that does not last for long once she finds out how boring it is to be holed up forever. She goes back home, only to return to save the island from a second Viking attack by bringing soldiers back to defeat them, a life of action she finds far more religiously satisfying than meditating upon stale psalms in solitude.

The book does have a relic of a saint (the finger of St. Columba), a resurrection and a ghost, and an illuminated manuscript (yes, a Kellsian echo), but at the very heart of it is the friction (heat, light, conflagration, illumination) of pagan and Celtic Christianity rubbing their bits together. For Martin, there is no higher achievement in life than to so melt into God’s presence as to lose all definition of self and thus avoid all struggle with desire and imperfection and sin.

Grimur, though tempted a little by the purity of such a formless life, ultimately cannot cotton to the Christian revocation of the real world around them. For instance, Martin rhapsodizes about the miracles that St. Columba’s finger made possible, and Grimur, responds, “Did he never pick his nose or wipe his arse?” When Martin, in another instance enthuses that God’s love is as boundless as the sea, Grimur replies, “The sea has boundaries.” (Greig puts all dialogue in italics, which gives it a strange urgency as it’s read.)

And then there is Grimur’s relationship with Una, who, as her name suggests, brings into one body (and her kick-ass honey mead) the redemptive energy of Martin’s God and the temporal finitude of Grimur’s Odin: “Unlike Martin, Grimur felt content. Why shouldn’t he? He was fed and fucked and far away from trouble. Perhaps this was what Christians meant by Heaven: a simple sufficiency?”

I incline toward the Grimurian point of view. At moments, what Martin considers a gift of grace from a bodiless God is simply a pause in nature’s constant effort to kill off all humans in as many exotic ways as possible: a moment of simple sufficiency may be enough of a reward for all of the existential chaos we have to endure as humans slouching toward death, with no need to muck it up with appeals to divinity or destiny.

Greig’s book, in one of the linkages that make life strange and tasty, led me to think about Henry David Thoreau – again – and lo, there was Ken Burn’s PBS documentary on the man. The three-episode biopic was fine, and it’s always good to re-hear Thoreau’s call to live life fully and hard, though, in the usual Burnsian fashion, all the good transgressive edges get smoothed away. Thoreau may have transcendentalized nature, but it was never Emerson’s vaporous initial-capped Nature, a poor proxy for the religion RWE had given up ages ago.

For Thoreau, being in the muck was critical to being in your right mind and body. Spirit emanated not from celestial places but from the sweaty satisfaction of building a cabin. Thoreau may have thought he was becoming an elevated being by sinking himself eye-deep in a swamp to swap gazes with a bullfrog, but he was actually feeling what Grimur, deep in Una’s embrace and with a horn of honey mead in hand, was marveling at: finding a space of simple sufficiency on the solid earth where the chaos stops and time shuts up and what is, is. Heaven enough, indeed.

I’m very excited about creating a play that avoids the sentimentalized Christian ethos that drives so much of our society’s narrative scripts (good guys should win, or at least the least-worst bad guy; sin is punished or at least good is rewarded; redemption is required). The pagan is sufficient; I hope I can honor it well. 

inView

May 2026

 

Share This Page

View readers’ comments in Letters to the Editor

Michael Bettencourt is an essayist and a playwright,
He is a Senior Writer and columnist for Scene4.
Continued thanks to his “prime mate"
and wife, María-Beatriz.
For more of his columns, articles, and media,
check the Archives.

©2026 Michael Bettencourt
©2026 Publication Scene4 Magazine

 

 

THEATRE THOUGHTS
and
OCCASIONAL MUSINGS

and creates
VIDEOS

 

YOUR SUPPORT

If you are enjoying this issue please consider lending a hand. Scene4 is a global magazine featuring reviews, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, photography, paintings, graphics and
poetry. Founded as a monthly in 2000, with over 300 issues during the past 26 years of publication and an accessible, comprehensive archive of over
18,000 pages (a unique array of articles as comtemporary as when they were first published).
In these disruptive times, we need your help and support to weather the storm. Please make a contribution of any size by going to our support page here and gather the appreciation of our authors, artists and editors.



 

  Sections This Issue · inFocus · inView · inSight · Perspectives · Special Issues
  Columns  Adler · Alenier · Alpaugh · Bettencourt · Gallas · Jones · Luce · Marcott · Walsh 
  Information Masthead · Your Support · Submissions · Archives · Books
  Connections          Contact Us · Comments · Subscribe · Letters

 | Search Archives | Share Page |

Scene4 (ISSN 1932-3603), published monthly by Scene4 Magazine
of Arts and Culture. Copyright © 2000-2026 Aviar-Dka Ltd – Aviar Media Llc.

May 2026