sc4-962-3d1
RS-1-Window-cr

Bournounville’s La Sylphide at SF Ballet: Not a Love Story

Renate Stendhal

Note: As SF Ballet was short on production photos of the different casts for La Sylphide, please notice that some photos show Danish guest Alban Lendorf (American Ballet Theater) and Joseph Walsh instead of Wei Wang whom I saw in the role of James.

It is a puzzle why American ballet companies tend to perform the Danish La Sylphide by Bournonville’s (1836) instead of the much more romantic original version by Taglioni, from 1832. The illustrious ballerina Marie Taglioni, his daughter, had danced the first Sylphide on pointe, apparently hardly touching the ground, reshaping classical ballet overnight. Bournonville had seen the ballet in Copenhagen and made the tale his own by considerably shortening it to a new score and sweeping off the romantic and erotic content with a cool norhern broom. In order to see the romance of La Sylphide you have to go to Paris or Italy-- or to YouTube.

RS-2-Sleep-cr
Alban Lendorf (photo: Lindsey Rallo)

SF Ballet’s reprisal of the Danish La Sylphide this April changed my opinion of it. I saw the ballet less as a weaker version than an altogether different affair. Ex-Princical dancer Ulrik Birkkjaer, a former member of the Royal Danish Ballet, who had starred in the ballet, polished up Helgi Tomassons’s  1987 production (that had a substantial overhaul already in 2004 and 2012). With the participation of SF Ballet’s artistic director, Tamara Rojo, the latest revival brought out the dark, cynical aspects in the story of a young Scotsman who falls for a sylph on his wedding day. This time, his chasing after an illusion comes across not as a fatal love story, but as a tale of greed, egoism and betrayal -- convincing and illuminating.

RS-3-Tease-cr
Alban Lendorf (photo: Lindsey Rallo)

Usually, the “romantic“ hero, James (Wei Wang), is depicted as a charmer with a mean streak, which doesn’t quite gel. Why sympathize with a guy who abandons his fiancee Effy (Carmela Mayo) and acts like a nasty control-freak? Should we feel sorry for him when he destroys the beautiful sylph (Wona Park) whom he cannot possess?

 In the new revival, James is a negative hero from the get-go. Principal Wei Wang, who trained in Bejing and at SF Ballet
School, hides his natural charm and plays a surly, arrogant fellow -- anything but a sensitive soul in love with a dream. As he chases aftrer the sylph, his sharp, precise footwork and explosive leaps do more than highlight the essential Bournonville style. The rapid battements, cross-beats of both legs in the air, that have to be executed with a rather immobile upper body, suddenly seem to express the obsessive character of James.

RS-4-Kiss-cr

The production also highlights aspects of comedy. James is indifferent to the the wedding reels with Effy and their guests. He has something else in mind while the men, women and kids in their Scottish dresses and kilts are having a jolly good time with the rapid tempi of the score (by Herman Severin Loevenskiold) and Bournonville’s stomping steps that seem to predict the staccato footwork of River Dance. He breaks away frantically whenever the slyph flits by. At the same time, he energetically defends his possession, Effy, againts his rival Gürn (a comically understated Fernando Carratala Coloma) who keeps trying to kiss her hand.

5-cr

One time, when James almost catches his butterfly she escapes up the chimney -- a moment of such perfect stage craft that it brought the house down. A darker comical presence is the old woman/witch. danced by the stunninly tall spindly Nathaniel Remez. He has fascinating twisted movements and over-the-top expressionist pantomimes as he/she reads people’s destiny from their hands and reacts to James’s meanness by promising him his just desserts.

RS-6-cr-Leap

In the second act, the forest, lyrical passages in the score support the traditional graceful wafting of the group of eighteen sylphs with their little wings and diaphanous tutus. It’s exciting to see Wei Way running among them, now with a tiny smile on his face, searching for his love object much like Prince Siegfried among the Swan Maidens or Albrecht among the Wilis of Giselle. Bournonville has his negative hero running all the time, chasing after the flighty sylph, leaping and running to and fro to get hold of her. The fact that he never does give us the rarety of a classical ballet without a pas de deux!

RS-7Group-cr

The high point of Wei Wang’s mastery comes when he toys with the poisoned scarf (supplied by the witch from a steaming cauldron). He makes the scarf dance in the air with the same exhilarating precision of his feet, throws it in beautiful arcs and catches it in his leaps, catches it in his leaps as if a second winged creature were flying about. Now the sylph has to chase after him and the alluing scarf. It’s a dramatic role reversal: he has the control over her desire. He lures her close, makes her kneel before him, and winds the scarf around her arms. Tied to him by force, her wings fall off and she dies. The “moral of the tale” plays out in the background where Effy is on her wedding march with Gürn.

RS-7-Scarf-cr

Joseph Walsh — photo: Erik Tomasson

With matching artistic finesse, South-Korean Principal Wona Park embodies the airy promise of a dream world. A former graduate from San Francisco Ballet Schoo, she impressed with her fluid arms, startling balances on pointe, high, soft leaps, and sensitive, musical phrasing. I found her enchanting and kept wondering about her artistic guidance by Tamara Rojo who has danced the role herself and is a superior role model for her company. The truly great Sylphides add an air of romantic longing and tragedy to the role. Wona Park, already graceful and light as a feather, can go even further when she allows herself to abandon her smiles and express emotion with her face. Like Rojo did, or Yuan Yuan Tan in 2004, or the great Carla Fracci, to name some of the best. No matter, it was a memorable achievement for both protagonists and the whole company. The SF Ballet Orchestra under Martin West played with particular freshness and verve to bring the old tale into the present moment.

Coda: a photo of the invisible hero of this review:

RS-89Wei-Wang-2-cr

Wei Wang — photo: Erik Tomasson

All other photos: Lindsay Rallo

 

inFocus

May 2026

 

Share This Page

View other readers’ comments in Letters to the Editor

Renate Stendhal , Ph.D. (www.renatestendhal.com) is a writer and interpersonal counselor based in the San Francisco Bay Area. Among her publications are the award-winning photo biography Gertrude Stein in Words and Pictures , and Kiss Me Again, Paris: A Memoir. Her articles and essays have appeared internationally. She is a Senior Writer for Scene4. For her other reviews and articles:, check the Archives.

Writings
Index of Renate Stendhal’s
writings and reviews
|

©2026 Renate Stendhal
©2026 Publication Scene4 Magazine

 

 

 

YOUR SUPPORT

If you are enjoying this issue please consider lending a hand. Scene4 is a global magazine featuring reviews, commentary, criticism, essays, fiction, photography, paintings, graphics and
poetry. Founded as a monthly in 2000, with over 300 issues during the past 26 years of publication and an accessible, comprehensive archive of over
18,000 pages (a unique array of articles as comtemporary as when they were first published).
In these disruptive times, we need your help and support to weather the storm. Please make a contribution of any size by going to our support page here and gather the appreciation of our authors, artists and editors.



 

  Sections This Issue · inFocus · inView · inSight · Perspectives · Special Issues
  Columns  Adler · Alenier · Alpaugh · Bettencourt · Gallas · Jones · Luce · Marcott · Walsh 
  Information Masthead · Your Support · Submissions · Archives · Books
  Connections          Contact Us · Comments · Subscribe · Letters

 | Search Archives | Share Page |

Scene4 (ISSN 1932-3603), published monthly by Scene4 Magazine
of Arts and Culture. Copyright © 2000-2026 Aviar-Dka Ltd – Aviar Media Llc.

May 2026